Category Archives: Philosophical

Q: What would happen if an unstoppable force met with an unmovable, impenetrable object?

Mathematician: Sometimes, when we don’t use language carefully enough, we can get ourselves into philosophical trouble. For example, consider the following statement: If a barber shaves all those men (and only those men) who do not shave themselves, does he … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, Brain Teaser, Philosophical | 32 Comments

Q: Can one truly create something from nothing? If matter formed from energy (as in the Big Bang expansion), where did the energy come from?

Physicist: That right there is one of the great unsolved questions.  Every experiment that’s ever been done (on this subject) verifies the conservation of mass and energy.  While the amount of mass or the amount of energy may change (they … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Philosophical, Physics, Quantum Theory | 62 Comments

Q: What is infinity? (A brief introduction to infinite sets, infinite limits, and infinite numbers)

Mathematician: To mathematicians, infinity is not a single entity, but rather a label given to a variety of related mathematical objects. What unites these “infinities” is that they are all, in some sense, larger than anything that can be obtained … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, Math, Philosophical | 9 Comments

Q: Is it of any coincidence that mathematics is able to describe physical reality – given that both are inventions of the human mind?

Physicist: There’s a lot of math that doesn’t describe physical reality at all, and even some (few) mathematicians who feel that “applicability” is just another word for “impurity”.  The ability of math to describe reality is just a consequence of … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, -- Guest Author, Evolution, Math, Paranoia, Philosophical | 3 Comments

Q: Is there a real life example where two negatives make a positive?

Physicist: Although the laws of the universe are very absolute, the equations and terms we use are generally easy to rewrite and rephrase.  For example: it seems natural to describe the motion of a ball in terms of its altitude.  … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Philosophical, Physics | 12 Comments

Q: Do the “laws” of physics and math exist? If so, where? Are they discovered or invented/created by humans?

The original question was: Mathematicians sometimes say, “There exists a number such that . . .”  Which provokes me to ask, Where does it exist? For how long has it existed? Did numbers exist before people did? Or did people … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Philosophical | 14 Comments