Category Archives: Philosophical

Q: Could Kurt Vonnegut’s “Ice-9 catastrophe” happen?

The original question was: Is it possible to actually create a substance such as Kurt Vonnegut’s “Ice-9 (Nine)“, which could, in theory, bond with water (especially seawater) and replicate like a virus, freezing the oceans (or all liquid water on … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Paranoia, Physics | 15 Comments

Q: What is the probability of an outcome after it’s already happened?

Physicist: There are a lot of subtleties to this.  Reading the question, your gut reaction should be “Duh, it’s 100%!  Wait, is this really a question?”. And yet, there are many times in which you may find yourself estimating probabilities … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Philosophical, Probability, Quantum Theory | 11 Comments

Q: How do you answer a question scientifically?

Mathematician: Suppose you’re interested in answering a simple question: how effective is aspirin at relieving headaches? If you want to have conviction in the answer, you’ll need to think surprisingly carefully about how you approach this question. A first idea … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, Math, Philosophical, Probability | 4 Comments

Q: What are singularities? Do they exist in nature?

Physicist: Singularities are just artifacts that fall out of math.  They show up a lot in theory, and (probably) never in nature.  The “singularities” most people have heard of are black hole singularities. In practice, when you’re calculating something in … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Math, Philosophical, Physics | 23 Comments

Q: Are the brain and consciousness quantum mechanical in nature?

Physicist: The extremely short, smart-ass answer to this is: of course!  Ultimately everything in the universe is built out of tiny quantum things and ultimately everything obeys quantum mechanical laws.  But that’s not really the spirit of the question, and … Continue reading

Posted in Biology, Philosophical, Physics, Quantum Theory | 11 Comments

Q: Is there an experiment which could provide conclusive evidence for either the Many Worlds or Copenhagen interpretations of quantum physics?

Physicist: Probably not. Tiny things don’t act the way they should.  You got super-positions, wave-like behavior, action at a distance, quantum tunneling, quantum teleportation, interaction-free detection, all kinds of things that should be impossible or paradoxical but aren’t.  The laws … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Experiments, Philosophical, Physics, Quantum Theory | 7 Comments