Category Archives: Philosophical

Q: CERN’s faster than light neutrino thing: WTF?

Physicist: The story here is that CERN has been generating neutrinos, firing them 730km, to a detector in Gran Sasso, Italy, and those neutrinos have been consistently (so far as their instruments say) arriving 60 ns (0.00000006 seconds) earlier than … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Experiments, Paranoia, Relativity, Skepticism | 32 Comments

Q: What’s the point of purely theoretical research?

Physicist: The classic answer to this question, due (possibly) to Franklin, is “what use is a new-born baby?”. The problem is that the best research/exploration is about looking for stuff, while not quite knowing what to expect or what to … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Mathematician, -- By the Physicist, Experiments, Philosophical, Skepticism | 4 Comments

Q: What is mass?

Physicist: Short questions are real killers! “Mass”, like practically everything in physics, is defined in terms of its properties, like: 1) Mass has inertia. 2) Mass creates gravity (energy does this too). 3) Mass travels slower than the speed of … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Philosophical, Physics | 7 Comments

Q: How much of physics can be deduced from previous equations/axioms?

The original question was: I was wondering quite how much of physics (mainly regarding classical mechanics but all branches!) can be deduced from previous equations/axioms. I don’t mean going as far back as what axioms we have to take in … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Philosophical | 12 Comments

Q: If God were all-seeing and all-knowing, the double-slit experiment wouldn’t work, would it? Wouldn’t God’s observation of the location of the photon collapse its probability wave function?

Physicist: Deep… It depends on how entangled God is with the rest of us. If He can make the observation, and then keep a completely straight face forever (never leak any information about the result in any way), then His … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Philosophical, Quantum Theory | 23 Comments

Q: Does light experience time?

The original question was: Given that light is moving at light speed, and time slows down as a massive object approaches the speed of light, does light travel through time?  Does the whole time slowing down thing just not apply … Continue reading

Posted in -- By the Physicist, Philosophical, Physics, Relativity | 120 Comments